Hello dear
Welcome To Subway New Albany
At Subway New Albany, we embrace our mission to serve delicious, fresh sandwiches and salads in a welcoming environment. Located at 5186 New Albany Rd, our family-run establishment focuses on exceptional customer service, highlighted by our friendly staff who ensure every visit is memorable. Our menu features crowd favorites like the Hot Honey Pepperoni and classic Black Forest Ham sandwiches, made with the freshest ingredients. Customers appreciate our clean, bright dining area and our commitment to quick, thoughtful service. Whether dining in or enjoying takeout, Subway New Albany is a place where delicious food meets heartfelt hospitality.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
#30 The Beast (1080 Cals)
$15.59#20 Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch (760 Cals)
$14.39#20 Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch (830 Cals)
$14.39
#11 Subway Club® (690 Cals)
$13.91#11 Subway Club® (410 Cals)
$13.91#10 All-American Club® (680 Cals)
$13.79
#10 All-American Club® (760 Cals)
$13.79#31 Cheesy Garlic Steak (700 Cals)
$13.19#16 All-Pro Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki® (480 Cals)
$13.19 About
Subway New Albany
Welcome to Subway New Albany, a delightful neighborhood gem located at 5186 New Albany Rd, New Albany, OH 43054. This beloved sandwich spot is renowned for its fresh ingredients, exceptional service, and inviting atmosphere, making it a perfect choice for lunch, breakfast, or a quick bite any time of day.
At Subway New Albany, the menu boasts an array of mouthwatering options, especially with their Subway® Series. Highlights include:
- Hot Honey Pepperoni - A limited-time offer, this sandwich features sweet and spicy pepperoni layered with 2x provolone cheese on toasted Italian Herbs & Cheese bread. Finished off with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and a decadent drizzle of Hot Honey sauce, it perfectly balances flavors that excite your palate. Priced at $6.59.
- Hot Honey Chicken - Another tempting limited-time option, this dish promises juicy flavor in every bite.
- #21 Honey Mustard BBQ Chicken Wrap - Indulge in juicy rotisserie-style chicken topped with melted Monterey Cheddar, crisp vegetables, and a tangy BBQ sauce, all wrapped in pillowy Lavash. A perfect balance of sweet and savory, priced at $13.19.
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese - Kickstart your day with this ultimate breakfast fave, featuring hickory-smoked bacon, fluffy eggs, and melty American cheese on a soft flatbread for just $5.99.
But it's not just the food that sets Subway New Albany apart. Based on glowing customer reviews, it's clear that the atmosphere and service play a significant role in the dining experience. Customers rave about the friendly staff, with many noting how employees greet every guest with warmth and positivity. Anna Rucker notes, “the service is exceptional and the food is always good!” Taylor Kamerer emphasizes how the staff keeps customers informed even during busy hours, ensuring a seamless lunch experience.
Moreover, the cleanliness and bright ambiance of the remodeled dine-in area add to the appeal. Sarah Hervey points out how the staff is not only friendly but also goes above and beyond to address any issues, proving their dedication to customer satisfaction.
If you’re looking for a delightful sandwich experience in a welcoming atmosphere, Subway New Albany is a must-visit. With fresh ingredients, an array of delicious offerings, and a commitment to outstanding service, this Subway location could easily become your go-to spot. Don't just take our word for it; swing by, grab a sandwich, and enjoy the warmth of this local favorite!
For any inquiries, feel free to contact them at (614) 775-9007.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ i work nearby, and grab subway often for lunch. the service is exceptional and the food is always good! the ladies working there are so kind easy to talk too! ”
“ Not sure if shes the manager or owner, but the woman greetingupdating people on their orders was excellent. Made sure to keep everyone current on their orders despite it being super busy. Exactly what Im looking for during my lunch hour!! ”
“ Subway hadnt been on my go to list for some time, but this young couple have put the franchise back at the top. I, with my very old mother in tow, now stop by this particular Subway every chance we get. They are friendly and fun, the establishment is clean, the bread and ingredients are fresh, and the finished product is delicious! Very highly recommended! And now, of course, I am starving! ”
“ I was immediately greeted by the employees, who were greeting every single customer when they entered and left the store, and the vibe of the store was extremely positive. I went in feeling good about my day and left feeling amazing. Kudos to the employees working today! They were so nice. Food was made quick and efficiently as well. No complaints! ”
“ Dine in area is remodeled, clean and bright. Staff, which seems to be family run, have been friendly and helpful. Great customer service. Most recently I had an issue with a door dash order and the woman who helped me was so kind, apologized and was quick to remedy the issue, above and beyond. Also, the food all was very fresh, bread was fresh and soft... All around great experiences here. ”
“ We love eating at Subway!! Their subs are so delicious yummy the best!!! Weve eaten at this Subway in New Albany, Ohio next to Wendys several times. The staff are very professional and super nice. They make our subs the way we order. I received a coupon for a free cookie because my birthday was few weeks back. My daughters birthday was a couple of days ago. My daughter said, to the cashier my moms birthday was few weeks ago and my birthday was couple of days ago. I told the cashier I was going to give the cookie to my daughter. He said, no you bought two meals you should have two cookies too. He gave us two cookies. The cashier was a gentleman a total sweetheart ”
“ Wasnt expecting much out of a subway but this establishment was beyond my expectations I just had to write a review. Remodeling inside but the second we walked in we were greeted. The owner of the store was making our subs and she was chatting with us the entire time. Asking questions and holding a strong convo. Family run business. She treated everyone who walked in the door with the same friendliness! Very happy we stopped in ”
“ This Subway is usually ran by the sweetest, most helpful and efficient woman, ever. If I could give it 10 stars, I would. The food is always exactly as requested and made on time. ”